How do you compare sustainable investment funds?
Sustainability plays a major role in our society today. The Nobel Prize for Economics recently went to ‘Climate Change & Innovation’, and that is of course not without reason. The topic of sustainability is also increasingly present in the investment world, which has led to a significant increase in the number of sustainable investment funds in recent years. But how can you, as an investor, best compare sustainable investment funds in order to make the best choice?
By following these steps, you can determine which sustainable investment fund suits you best, using a number of criteria.
Sustainable investing is still in full development
Through sustainable investment, investments are made in companies that are happy to contribute to a world with respect for people, the environment and society. Despite the fact that the number of sustainable investment funds has increased significantly, it is still a part of the investment world with a lot of development. Think for example of the regulations and the various laws surrounding green investments. There are also tax benefits for green funds .
There are already a number of guidelines, such as the Global Compact Guidelines (UNGC). These include the ten principles of the United Nations for the protection of human rights, labor, the environment and the prevention of corruption. In addition, the UN Principles for Responsible Investment (UNPRI) were signed in 2016 by more than 1,500 asset managers and owners with assets under management worth 60 trillion dollars.
Defining sustainable investing
But when is an investment fund really sustainable? There are a lot of terms, abbreviations and themes within sustainable investing; SRI (Socially Responsible Investment), ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance), green, sustainable and responsible. This is just a small selection from the entire list, which may make it difficult for investors to see the forest for the trees. According to AF Advisors, a sustainable investment fund must at least meet the following requirements:
- A clear ESG policy with engagement
- An active right to vote
- The ability to apply exclusion criteria to negative screening (excluding categories such as tobacco and arms trade)
In addition, the fund manager’s overarching ESG policy is examined and checked to ensure that this policy is applied correctly.
5 criteria for comparing sustainable investment funds
1. Determine which level of sustainability suits you
First of all, it is important to determine what your personal expectations are for an ESG investment. You can distinguish five levels here.
- Legal minimum: Many index trackers fall under this, these funds only meet the legal minimum.
- Standard level: The fund managers apply a minimal ESG policy, with limited engagement and voting rights.
- Integrated approach: In this case, every investment in the fund is assessed using ESG standards. In addition, the investment funds have a clear exclusion policy for certain companies and/or sectors. For example, companies in the tobacco or metal industry.
- Best in class: In these types of funds, positive screening is applied. This means that within a certain industry or category, companies are selected based on the best scores on ESG issues that play a role in the industry in question. For example, companies or institutions with lower emissions; these are given a higher weight in the wallet.
- Impact investing: This involves achieving measurable and sustainable impacts and/or achievements. Examples include energy conservation, clean drinking water, gender equality and the fight against child labour.

2. See how the investments are selected
It is important to understand how the various selection procedures are conducted and how they are evaluated. Not every investment fund attaches the same values to all ESG criteria. In addition, the investment opportunities and the prospects of the return can differ per fund.
3. Check how the investment fund is performing
An investment fund should not only have the potential to set goals, but also to actually achieve them. That is why it is wise to check how an ESG fund has performed, both in terms of financials and sustainability. Is that clearly communicated to the investor? And what was the return in previous years?
4. Determine how much risk you want to take
As with other investment matters, it is important to know in advance how much risk you want to take. Is this your only investment, or do you have more investments? A specialized fund involves more risk than other funds. Especially for smaller, private investors, it can be an unwise choice to focus on one specific theme or fund. It is better to spread the chances.
5. Determine your preferences within sustainable investing
Not all investors are the same. For example, you may attach more value to how sustainable an ESG fund is, while someone else may find decent wages and suitable employment conditions important. So ask yourself: What do I find most important? Is it developing healthier food, or promoting ecologically responsible pesticides? Do you want to contribute to a better climate, or do you find a vegetarian lifestyle more important? Green funds have different values in all these different areas, which you as an investor must take into account.
Compare brokers and start investing in mutual funds
Are you excited about investment funds after reading this article? Check out the range of brokers with different funds and find the broker that suits you best!