Shared under ten

You can follow our portfolio and take advantage of it. Our portfolio is not a buy recommendation.

Green investing in indices

Myths about green index investing

Investing does not always have to be in companies that spend the money incorrectly, for example on weapons or other matters that have negative consequences for people and the environment. There are also a large number of sustainable  indices  in which you can invest. It is predicted that sustainable investment via passive index funds will grow within a few years. Not everyone agrees with this. A number of active managers claim that it is not possible to combine sustainable with passive. There is a lot to be said about the arguments they have for this. In this article you can read more about green investing in an index.

Myth 1: Sustainable indexes are a ‘black box’, 

For example, it is said that sustainable indexes are part of a black box. As an investor, you would not know what you are buying if you buy a sustainable index fund. This is not always the case. Often you can easily look up what you are investing in. Of course, it is not the case that managers will always tell you what they have done in detail to achieve their outperformance. Sometimes it remains guesswork about all the sustainable considerations that came into play when putting together the portfolio. In addition, generalizing between the different indexes is not realistic, because one index is not the same as the other. 

The approach to the composition within an index is also not always the same. To give an example, we can look at the funds of ESG and Northern Trust. These two funds use almost the same approach. Then you have iShares, for example. These funds are mainly concerned with water, alternative energy and sustainable indices. The holdings of these funds can simply be found daily on the website of the provider. So there is no black box at all, because investors simply have a good insight into the status of the funds.

Myth 2: Sustainability scores are ‘inconsistent’ (and that’s bad)

In addition, it is said that sustainability scores are inconsistent. The companies Systainalytics and MSCI assess the sustainability of companies. The importance of these sustainability scores can increase and this in turn has an influence on the creation of a sustainable index. The judgments that result from this are increasingly being questioned. For example, it is indicated that these parties sometimes differ in opinion. The term inconsistent is used for this.

The agencies do not all think the same about the sustainability level of companies such as Apple. This is somewhat comparable to the analyses that credit rating agencies and financial analysts do. In this case, opinions do not always point in the same direction. They all look at the same company, but opinions can differ. This has the advantage that it can create a financial market in the first place. This would never have been possible if everyone had shared the same opinion. A difference of opinion is not necessarily inconsistent.

Myth 3: Active managers are ‘more active’ than passive managers

Finally, it is said that active managers are more active than passive managers. Active ownership can be thought of as, for example, having votes during shareholder meetings or entering into dialogues with the companies in which one invests. The active managers, i.e. the managers who do participate in this, claim that they make much more and better efforts than their passive colleagues. By making these kinds of statements, a dividing line is created between passive and active managers. In practice, this dividing line does not appear to be so sharp. Many fund houses manage both passive and active strategies. When it comes to casting votes or entering into dialogues with the companies, all interests are often lumped together and the funds act in the same way.

In summary, it can be said that sustainable indices and therefore investing in a green index do not exist. There are many sustainable index strategies and therefore also many ways of applying transparency or the way in which it is all filled in. Both funds, both the passive sustainable and the active sustainable, are filled in on the basis of opinions. It is not possible to attach one truth to this. There is no truth to attach to the sustainability of a company, because there will always be many opinions about this. In addition, a strict separation between active and passion managers is also nonsense. This dividing line often does not exist in practice, and this also applies to the differences between  active and passive investment funds . In practice, it works differently in both areas than theory would have us believe.

Compare brokers and start index investing

Are you excited about index investing after reading this article about ‘green index investing’?  Compare brokers with index investing  and find the broker that suits you best!

Verder lezen?

Dit artikel is alleen voor abonnees van Aandelen Onder Een Tientje. Indien u nog geen abonnee bent, overweegt u dan ook een abonnement.

Join thousands of others?

Become a member now and get instant access to our entire platform. 

The value we offer:

Lees ook

No posts found!

CFD short position

CFD Trading: Going Long CFD stands for Contract for Difference . This is a simple way to trade that allows you to make the most of your money. A Contract for Difference is a binding contract, where the seller or buyer will pay the difference between the current value of a share and a future value, to the other at the time the buyer chooses to close the contract. Is the value greater? Then the seller of the contract (the broker) pays the buyer. Has the value decreased? Then the buyer must pay more to the seller. A CFD is a derivative , meaning that it derives its value from an underlying asset, often a stock or a market index. As the buyer of a CFD, you do not own the underlying asset and are never entitled to it. It is only used to value the contract. Taking a long position with CFDs ‘ Going long ‘ is simply buying a CFD position when you expect  the stock price  to rise. A ‘long position’ is taken when an investor believes the market will rise. This is a common way to  trade CFDs . Going long in CFDs is similar to the position you would take when buying shares, for example. As a trader, you first buy the position and then sell it at a later date to close out the trade. The difference between the purchase price and the sale price is the profit or loss made on the trade. The opposite of ‘going long’ is ‘going short’ or taking a ‘short position’. In this case you assume a decrease in value from which you can profit. Buy CFD: margin When you go long with CFDs, you don’t need to have enough money to buy the asset you are trading. The amount of money you need, or ‘margin’, depends on  the broker  and what you are trading. For example, for shares you might need 10% and for other securities it might be even less. This leverage allows you to make the most of your money, as the contract still benefits from the amount the asset changes in value. Simply put, if you only put down 10% and the underlying share increases in price by 10%, you have doubled your money. We will illustrate this with an example in which we also include the necessary incidental costs that come with CFD trading. Suppose you expect the shares of company X, which currently cost €1.25, to increase in value. You want to take a long CFD position for 1000 shares. The value of this is €1500, but you do not need that much cash. CFDs of 10% require a deposit of only €150. You also pay a small commission ( a spread ) to the broker. Two weeks later, the shares have each risen to €1.35 and you decide to close the CFD position. For every day that you hold CFDs, interest is charged. In effect, you are borrowing money to maintain your position in the shares. This interest is related to the bank interest rate. For this example, we assume that the interest is €5. You close the position with a profit of 10 cents per share and have to pay a trading commission again. The net profit is 1000 x 10 cents, minus two commissions and the interest, which totals €95. This is a profit of more than 60% of the stake. Long CFD trading, a profitable example To open a long position, you will need to place an order to buy the CFD you want. Each broker will use a slightly different method to place orders, but if you have bought a stock before, it is very easy to make the transition to CFDs. To go short, you need to place an order to sell the CFD. The way the order is placed depends on the broker you use. Opening the position Let’s say company XYZ is listed at €4.24 / 4.25. You expect the price to rise and decide to buy 15,000 shares as a CFD at €4.24. This bid price gives you a position size of €63,600 (15,000 x €4.24). Next, we assume a margin requirement of 10%. When placing the order, €6,360 is allocated from your account to the trade as initial margin. Be aware that if the position moves against you, i.e. the price falls instead of rising, it is possible to lose more than this margin of €6,360. For the same amount, you could only buy 1,500 shares with a regular stockbroker. In this example, commission is charged at 10 basis points (one basis point is 0.01 percentage points). So the commission on this trade is only 0.1% or approximately €63 (15,000 shares x €4.24 x 0.1%). You now have a position of 15,000 XYZ CFDs worth €63,600. Close CFD position A month later, the price of XYZ has risen to €4.68 / 4.69. Your expectation that the price would rise proves correct and you decide to take your profit. You sell 15,000 shares at the bid price, €4.68. The commission of 10 basis points will also apply to the closing of the transaction and amounts to €70 (15,000 shares x €4.68 x 0.1%). The gross profit on the transaction is calculated as follows: Slot level: €4.68 Opening level: €4.24 Difference: 0.44 Gross profit on the trade: €0.44 x 15,000 shares = €6,600. After deducting the commission costs (€63 + €70) from the total turnover, you realise a profit of €6,467. To determine the total profit on the transaction, you must also take into account the commission you paid and interest and dividend adjustments. Long CFD trade, a loss-making example It is also possible that the CFD does not do what you expected in advance and decreases in value while you have opened a long position. With this calculation example we show what the financial consequences of this are. Shares in company ABC are traded for €8.33 / €8.34. You think the price

Lees verder >

What is a share?

Een aandeel is eigenlijk een stukje van een bedrijf. Met één of meerdere aandelen ben je voor dat deel financieel eigenaar van een bedrijf. Gaat het goed met een bedrijf, dan profiteer jij hiervan. Lees meer…

Lees verder >

Preferred shares

Preferente aandelen geven jou extra voordelen over gewone aandelen. Zeker als je graag een vast dividend ontvangt. Lees meer…

Lees verder >